Games like The Gretlow Tapes

Still thinking about The Gretlow Tapes and its mysterious and atmospheric tone? These games offer a similar pull for your backlog.

Cheaper than The Gretlow Tapes

The title logo Paranormal VHS appears in white, grainy text against a dark, noisy background.

Paranormal VHS

Paranormal VHS is a horror game that features a VHS tape-inspired aesthetic.

70% of 137 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
The Silence Channel logo appears over a grainy photo of a faceless groom and a veiled bride covering her face.

Silence Channel

Based on a chilling true story, Silence Channel is a first person psychological horror game.

79% of 157 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
The title logo Abandoned Souls appears in white distressed text over a dark forest background with scan lines.

Abandoned Souls

Abandoned Souls is a horror game, shown through a GoPro lens. You play as a vlogger who specializes in urban exploration.

72% of 374 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
The red title logo Witch's Doll appears next to a pale figure with long claws peeking from darkness.

Witch's Doll

Witch's Doll is a first-person psychological horror game with realistic graphics. Beware, something is lurking in the dark.

85% of 267 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
The title logo THE TAPE appears in scratchy white text next to a pale, distorted mask with black eye streaks.

The Tape

The Tape is a slow and creepy first person horror game, with mystical story and abstract psychological elements.

53% of 367 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
The Ethel logo appears above a figure with long dark hair facing away in a dim room.

Ethel

Welcome to my first game! Where you'll Immerse yourself in a unbelievable, story-rich mystery, packed with jaw-dropping plot twist, horror, and…

93% of 240 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
The Mists of Aiden logo appears beside three polaroid photos showing a shadowy mansion and grotesque faces.

Mists of Aiden

Mists of Aiden is a first-person story driven horror game. You play as a thief trapped in an eerie mansion.

90% of 982 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
The Maid logo appears next to a creepy doll with red hair and a wide grin standing in a doorway.

The Maid

The Maid is a first-person psychological horror and mystery game that focuses on creating fear and tension in the player.

79% of 168 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
The Rehaunted logo appears below a red banner reading Major Halloween Update next to a grinning horror figure.

Rehaunted

Search a realistic crime scene with UV tools, camera and radio contact, then connect the contradictions into your own conclusion.

71% of 444 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$7.99
The title logo From The Darkness appears in white scratchy text over a dark, bloodstained door.

From The Darkness

Walk an abandoned apartment, hunt for a family album, and face what lives in the dark.

89% of 3,083 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$6.99
A pale, smiling elderly woman peers through green bars beside the white Dread Flats logo with red accents.

Dread Flats

Search a 1990s apartment block for the people who went missing while something stalks its corridors.

83% of 1,500 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$5.99
A typewriter sits above the title 'Who am I: Remedy' covering the eyes of a dark, monstrous figure.

Who am I: Remedy

A found footage horror game where you'll try to remember who you are and escape the time loop while documenting everything on a typewriter.

85% of 33 Steam reviews are positive$8.99

Hidden gems like The Gretlow Tapes

A figure with a carved wooden mask and glowing red eyes stands beside the dripping red title logo The Wellmonts Case.

The Wellmonts Case

The Wellmonts Case is a first-person psychological horror game set in 1993, Northern Maine.

95% of 235 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
A screaming ghost face looms behind the dripping title logo Coincidences?

Coincidences?

After a sudden rent hike, you move into a suspiciously cheap house deep in the woods.

91% of 424 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$3.99
Two girls holding a flashlight stand before a looming shadowy figure with glowing eyes, next to the game title logo.

Fear the Spotlight

Fear the Spotlight is an atmospheric third-person horror adventure with a disturbing mystery to unravel.

96% of 1,240 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$19.99
The For Sale logo appears next to hands holding a digital camera displaying a photo of a cat on its screen.

For Sale

The year is 1998. Step into the shoes of a real estate agent, tasked with photographing a seemingly ordinary house for an upcoming sale.

96% of 253 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
A woman stands with outstretched arms surrounded by reaching hands next to the distressed Among Ashes logo.

Among Ashes

Among Ashes is a terrifying first-person survival horror game.

95% of 443 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
A masked figure stands in red light beside a camera recording view of a hallway, with the title DON'T PLAY THIS overlaid.

Don't Play This

Step into five recordings where the tape stops at someone's death, and experience what came before it.

84% of 1,101 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$8.99
The Witchblood logo in red splatter appears next to a decaying figure being grabbed by a shadowy monster.

Witchblood

Witchblood is a first-person psychological horror game that draws you into the heart of a dark curse.

82% of 139 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
A pale, smiling elderly woman peers through green bars beside the white Dread Flats logo with red accents.

Dread Flats

Search a 1990s apartment block for the people who went missing while something stalks its corridors.

83% of 1,500 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$5.99
The Ethel logo appears above a figure with long dark hair facing away in a dim room.

Ethel

Welcome to my first game! Where you'll Immerse yourself in a unbelievable, story-rich mystery, packed with jaw-dropping plot twist, horror, and…

93% of 240 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
The Unspoken logo appears above a close-up of bloodshot eyes with green irises on a grainy VHS screen.

Unspoken

You find yourself in the center of inexplicable nightmare. Make your way through the horror, come face to face with terrible events.

89% of 791 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
The title Lost Luminosity appears in dripping red letters beside a decaying, skull-like face against a dark background.

Lost Luminosity

The inheritance following his mother’s death turns into a series of mysterious events for Sam.

83% of 243 Steam reviews are positive$3.99

Newest games like The Gretlow Tapes

The Rehaunted logo appears below a red banner reading Major Halloween Update next to a grinning horror figure.

Rehaunted

Search a realistic crime scene with UV tools, camera and radio contact, then connect the contradictions into your own conclusion.

71% of 444 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$7.99
The Witchblood logo in red splatter appears next to a decaying figure being grabbed by a shadowy monster.

Witchblood

Witchblood is a first-person psychological horror game that draws you into the heart of a dark curse.

82% of 139 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
A screaming ghost face looms behind the dripping title logo Coincidences?

Coincidences?

After a sudden rent hike, you move into a suspiciously cheap house deep in the woods.

91% of 424 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$3.99
A masked figure stands in red light beside a camera recording view of a hallway, with the title DON'T PLAY THIS overlaid.

Don't Play This

Step into five recordings where the tape stops at someone's death, and experience what came before it.

84% of 1,101 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$8.99
A typewriter sits above the title 'Who am I: Remedy' covering the eyes of a dark, monstrous figure.

Who am I: Remedy

A found footage horror game where you'll try to remember who you are and escape the time loop while documenting everything on a typewriter.

85% of 33 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
A figure with a carved wooden mask and glowing red eyes stands beside the dripping red title logo The Wellmonts Case.

The Wellmonts Case

The Wellmonts Case is a first-person psychological horror game set in 1993, Northern Maine.

95% of 235 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
The red dripping title Unmourned appears beside a pale, blood-streaked face against a dark background.

Unmourned

Unmourned is a first-person psychological horror game where Jason moves into a new house only to be haunted by escalating paranormal events.

79% of 266 Steam reviews are positive$24.99
The red dripping logo Gaze of Dread sits beside a screaming pale figure with glowing yellow eyes against a dark red moon.

Gaze of Dread

Mary Thorne retreats to Valley View Escape to focus on her project while waiting for her friend Carly. What begins as a calm week starts to feel… off.

100% of 35 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
A road stretches toward a glowing orange moon under silhouettes of hanging figures, with the red title "THE DERAILED" centered.

The Derailed

The Derailed is a first-person psychological horror game. Beneath the dusty arches of a nearly forgotten depot, shadows of the past tremble.

81% of 137 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
The title Lost Luminosity appears in dripping red letters beside a decaying, skull-like face against a dark background.

Lost Luminosity

The inheritance following his mother’s death turns into a series of mysterious events for Sam.

83% of 243 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
A distressed woman with dark makeup faces forward while reaching hands emerge from the shadows beside the Nightmare Shift logo.

Nightmare Shift

Take on night shifts at a remote motel, handle unsettling guests, and navigate eerie events.

73% of 216 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
A pale, smiling elderly woman peers through green bars beside the white Dread Flats logo with red accents.

Dread Flats

Search a 1990s apartment block for the people who went missing while something stalks its corridors.

83% of 1,500 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$5.99